Lower Decks’ Premiere Sends Up Modern Starfleet Distrust

The key distinction between Star Wars and Star Trek is a distinction in philosophy. Star Wars is about how each political system will ultimately fail its individuals, a pattern Andor will proceed. Star Trek, alternatively, suggests the “good” system might be constructed, exemplified by the Federation — which makes it curious that the Star Trek: Lower Decks Season 3 premiere is a send-up of a deep mistrust within the functionality of Starfleet.

Yet, if one considers the context of most trendy Star Trek, a thread of mistrust in political establishments, particularly Starfleet, runs by it, even within the season finale of Strange New Worlds. The first two seasons of Star Trek: Discovery handled a collection of corrupt Starfleet officers, together with the favourite “unhealthy” authorities operatives in Section 31. The first season of Star Trek: Picard confirmed a Starfleet infiltrated by enemies, and the second season confirmed how fragile this supposedly good system actually might be. Since Star Trek is at all times reflective of the sociopolitical occasions wherein its created, this is sensible. At least within the United States, mistrust in public establishments is extremely excessive. However, “Grounded” takes these notions in different Star Trek exhibits and infects the Lower Decks crew with it. Specifically, Ensign Mariner, voiced by Tawny Newsome, is suspicious as a result of her mom was arrested, falsely accused of a terrorist assault.

RELATED: Nichelle Nichols Was Star Trek’s Most Important Actor

The crew then engages in a collection of traditional Lower Decks hijinks so as to mount a rescue mission, busting Mariner’s mom out of the brig. Naturally, issues get progressively worse (which means: more and more funnier) till her mom has to swoop in on the finish to rescue them, after having been cleared of all costs. The greatest gag within the present is that, regardless of all of the mistrust in Starfleet, the utopian establishment cracked the thriller with surprisingly little effort. It’s this kind of meta commentary on the franchise that makes this collection such an underappreciated gem. While the “severe” exhibits are all caught up in trendy mistrust of establishments, Star Trek: Lower Decks reminds its followers (and perhaps their Trek colleagues) that Starfleet is, in the end, a pressure for good of their universe.

The resolution to inform these tales suspicious of establishments within the Star Trek universe is a supply of controversy for some followers. Part of their enjoyment of those tales are that the longer term is so fictionally good. In earlier exhibits and movies, even when Starfleet will get it fallacious, they’re often fast to come back round. However, ranging from Star Trek: Into Darkness, a contemporary anti-institutional perspective threaded itself by successive tales. Again, given the realities of the present-day world these tales touch upon, this pattern is sensible, if solely to maintain the allegory related to trendy audiences. Yet, a part of the explanation some Trek followers have turned to The Orville for his or her Trek-like tales is that it is extra akin to the Brannon Braga period of the ultimate frontier. (This additionally is sensible since Braga is a producer on the collection.)

RELATED: Strange New Worlds Should Let Pike Escape His Star Trek Fate

One of the good particulars on Lower Decks is that, with out absolutely breaking the fourth wall, the crew are followers of Star Trek. Sure, to them, it is “Starfleet historical past,” however the historical past they love essentially the most simply occurs to be the historical past audiences noticed play out onscreen over the previous 50-plus years of the franchise. The punchline of this episode being that Starfleet nonetheless has it (principally) collectively is even funnier contemplating this context. Subverting fan expectations creates drama, however a double subversion like this makes for even higher comedy.

Star Trek: Lower Decks might be an outrageous collection, and the present’s major objective is at all times to get fun. Yet, it nonetheless places collectively traditional Star Trek-style adventures, together with the outdated “crew steals the ship” gag. Making it an precise gag is an impressed selection and guarantees that Lower Decks will proceed to ship this season.

See what the Star Trek: Lower Decks crew will get as much as subsequent when new episodes debut Thursdays on Paramount+.