- Advertisement -

Last Updated: 1 year ago


The following incorporates spoilers for House of the Dragon Season 1, Episode 1, “The Heirs of the Dragon,” which aired Sunday, Aug. 21 on HBO. It additionally incorporates discussions of violence.

House of the Dragon‘s premiere episode accomplishes a lot of what made Game of Thrones distinctive. Disturbing incestuous {couples}? Check. Sex scenes and dragons? Check. Violence towards ladies? Check, and sadly, not completely progressive in the best way the present needs the violence to be perceived.

The scene in query is the now-infamous birthing scene. Aemma Targaryen, who has had being pregnant issues prior to now, is about to present delivery. When the child is breached, the maester asks her husband Viserys how they need to proceed. Viserys chooses to avoid wasting the child over Aemma, who the maester signifies might be going to die regardless. The catch is, the C-section would end in a horrific demise — one thing she begs Viserys to not enable. Yet he permits it anyway. The scene is violent. It’s horrifying to observe. It would not be stunning if many viewers needed to cover behind their fingers watching the scene. But what makes the scene insufferable is Viserys’ say in how violent the delivery is.

RELATED: George R.R. Martin Likens THAT Gory House of the Dragon Scene to GoT’s Red Wedding

Game of Thrones typically depends on the idea that for a person to be evil, he should do horrible issues to ladies — extra particularly, sexually violent acts (i.e. Khal Drogo, Joffrey Baratheon, Ramsay Bolton and Craster). Of course, this is not all the time the case, however the majority stands. Now Viserys in House of the Dragon has joined the pack of culprits responsible of propping themselves up by the deaths and/or downfall of ladies. Apparently, Viserys’ blind allegiance to his brutally merciless brother is not sufficient. He needed to order the homicide of his spouse to be nuanced and three-dimensional.

On one hand, it’s refreshing to see a delivery scene that’s not romanticized. Childbirth may be ugly and bloody, and portraying it because it actually is brings mild to that. On the opposite hand, it’s nonetheless a lady dying to present perception into a person’s character — as if there’s no different approach to take action. The scene confirms {that a} man’s story can not transfer ahead with no lady struggling for it. And House of the Dragon has managed to one way or the other up Game of Thrones‘ violence towards ladies in a sneaky, murderous approach by masking it as an vital second — one which portrays the fact for girls throughout that period and even now.

In a post-Roe v. Wade period in America, the scene hits laborious for a lot of ladies. The lack of consent resonates with the fact that also right now many ladies do not have management over their our bodies. What’s extra, Viserys’ function within the delivery is far more than only a involved father: he is each the legislation and the daddy. His choice to not let Aemma die a peaceful-ish demise is politically-based. He takes away her selection in how she needs to die the second he is aware of there may be the opportunity of having an inheritor. At that second, Aemma is not his spouse. She is a vessel for the way forward for Westeros.

RELATED: One Scene in House of the Dragon Makes Daenerys’ Death Even Sadder

The scene performs out towards a violent tourney occasion that goes haywire. Daemon (performed menacingly by Matt Smith) and different individuals bludgeon one another to demise. Spectators stand in shock and puke on the sight, but do nothing to cease it. Members of the royal household are even entertained by the flip of occasions. When Criston Cole and Daemon stand in victory by way of making it out alive, surrounded by useless our bodies, the viewers cheers. In the birthing scene, Viserys and the maesters rip Aemma to shreds to ship the child. She is the useless soldier that everybody has forgotten about as a result of in Viserys’ eyes, her job is completed. She is nugatory to him.

What involves thoughts after considering Aemma’s delivery is Lyanna Stark’s personal delivery in Game of Thrones — a strikingly comparable, but very completely different tackle the complicated nature of childbirth. Lyanna was by no means strapped down towards her will and compelled to present delivery to a Targaryen inheritor. Her delivery, like Aemma’s, was naturally difficult and he or she died from blood loss. But Lyanna had the help of her husband, brother and her moist nurses comforting her till the very finish. Her demise was tragic, however she wasn’t violated, and it despatched a extra acceptable message for the battlefield ladies face whereas on the childbed.

House of the Dragon deserves credit score the place it is due — it’s trustworthy. As Aemma tells Rhaenyra, the childbed was a ladies’s battlefield throughout that age. Child-birthing was probably the most harmful job a lady may do, and sadly, males typically had a say in how it will play out. Showrunner Miguel Sapochnik promised they had been tuning down the sexual violence within the spinoff, however is murdering ladies for the sake of a person’s dynamic characterization any higher? There’s a effective line House of the Dragon is strolling on, and with many delivery scenes to return, it might need hassle discovering its steadiness.

House of the Dragon airs Sundays at 9:00 p.m. on HBO and streams on HBO Max.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.